[qadianism] Re: negative evidence showing there can be no prophet after Rasulullah (s.a.w.)
By Abdul Aziz @axe.humboldt.edu
6:23pm
Thu
4
Feb

Mr. McKlosky: Please read reaponse to your questions from an Ahmadi.

On Wed, 3 Feb 1999, Umar Aadil Abdul Rahman McKloskey wrote:

> Some questions to ask qadianis:
> 
> 1. Allah mentioned the coming of prophets in earlier revelations. 
> He didn't mention any such coming in all of the Holy Qur'an, 
> revealed over a period of 22 years. Why?
> --------------------------------------------------
Allah (swa) exhorts all children of Adam to follow whenever a prophet
appears. (see Al'Araaf ayah 35). Now if no prophet was to be sent by God
then why did He say so. To deceive us? Please note that this ayah is in
command mode and in no way can you interpret it as a command to those
people who died before the appearance of Prophet Muhammad (SAS)
----------------------------------------------------------------- 
> 2. There is voluminous evidence that  Rasulullah (s.a.w.) mentioned 
> the coming of a reviver of religious sciences in each century; he
> also mentioned the return of Isa (p.b.u.h.). But there is no 
> evidence that he ever mentioned the coming of a new prophet after 
> him. Why?
> -------------------------------------------------
There is no doubt that Prophet Muhammad (SAS) spoke at length about the
coming of Jesus as Mahdi to Muslim ummah. It does not mean that Mahdi will
be in the body of old Jesus. It can be proved from Quran that Jesus died a
natural death and when a person dies then Quran says that his soul will
not be returned till the day of qiama. Also if you study bilble you find
similar wrong belief among the Jews. Bible says that before the coming of
Messiah (Jesus) another Prophet (Elijah) whom was taken to heaven earlier
will return. When the Jews asked Issa (AS) about the return of Elijah, his
answer was that the prophesy was fullfilled in the person of prophet John.
Now let us assume the coming of Messiah for Muslims is to be fullfilled by
the coming of the very old Jesus. Since he is now going to be for the
whole world and not only for the Jews, they will ask him to explain his
answer which he gave them when ha came first time. They will say that
either you lied first time or you are lying now. Last time you said that
second coming was fullfilled in tha appearance of another person and now
you say it is fullfilled in the appearance of the same person.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 3. There are no dua's to ask for the coming of a new prophet in times
>  of trouble. Why?
> -------------------------------
While you are considering me answers to your querries InshaAllah in a few
days time I shall respond to the rest. Wassalaam.
------------------------------------------------------
> 4. Even in the worst of times, under the Mongol hordes, or other 
> calamities, there is no evidence that any Muslim ever asked Allah
> to send us another prophet. Why?
> 
> 5. For 1,300 years before the qadianis, no school of thought 
> emerged among the Muslims that believed in the coming of a new
> prophet. Why?
> 
> 6. Rasulullah (s.a.w.) mentioned specifically that he would be
> followed by 30 false prophets. He did not mention that even 
> one true prophet would follow him, or provide us with any 
> indication of how such a new prophet should evidence himself.
> Surely Rasulullah (s.a.w.) knew that telling us about many 
> false prophets without telling us how to distinguish between 
> the true and the false would confuse us. Unless, of course, 
> there were no new prophets to come after him. Why?
> 
------------------------------------------------------------------------
eGroup home: http://www.eGroups.com/list/qadianism