[qadianism] Re: The Finality of Prophethood - Concensus of Scholars
By Irshad @irshad.org

> Abdul Aziz:
> Mr. Rashid: If you want to insist that Mirza Sahib abrogated
> Jihad permanently inspite of Ahmadis saying otherwise, then
> we can leave it to God. No use to argue. After all Christian
> have not accepted Muslim's argument in favor of Islam.

Once more, dear brother, you seem to have fallen for the old 
fallacy of trying to force a parallel between Christians not 
accepting Islam and Muslims not accepting Qadianism!  Well, 
did Muslims accept Musailma and was there something wrong with
it?  Obviously, just because Muslims reject the claims of Mirza
Ghulam and his partners, it does not make him right.  Historically,
we have not accepted the claims of any claimant to prophethood.
Are you telling us that all of them were true prophets?!!!  How
about all the Qadianis who claimed prophethood and were rejected
by your leadership?  Were they also rightly guided?

Brother Rashid has presented well documented evidence in support
of his allegation.  I hope you too will bring similar evidence in
support of your view.  Otherwise, some might think that you are 
purposely avoiding the issue.  Simply because you have not read
the complete writings of your founders, it does not mean that 
they do not exist.  We Muslims do not reject your personal ideas,
but those of your founders.  If you are representing Ahmadiyyat,
then kindly please evidence from the writings of the founders and
leaders of the movement.

Thank you.

eGroup home: http://www.eGroups.com/list/qadianism