| [qadianism] Re: The Finality of Prophethood - Concensus of Scholars By Farhan Qureshi @yahoo.com |
|
Asslaamu Alaikum, Let me ask you this: What Great Haqq, or Big entitlement does being the Last Prophet give to the Holy Prophet (saw). He is the SEAL: Al Khatam. To be the last Prophet is a sad statement. That means Allah (SWT), does not want to guide us any-more: and what about the second coming of Isa(as), will he not be a Prophet??? Wasslaam, Farhan http://www.freeyellow.com/members4/ahmadiyyat/islam.html All respect is Due to the Greatest Prophet, Al Khatuman Nabiyyan, Muhammad Mustufa bin Abdullah bin Abu Mutalib Rasuulullahe (SAW)!!!!!!!!!!!! Love for all Hatred towards None. I bear witness: There is none worthy of worship exept Allah and I bear witness: Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. --- irsha-@irshad.org wrote: > > Dear friend, > > There have been a number of individuals alleging a disagreement > between Muslim Scholars of worth on the question of the Finality > of Prohethood. In all years of my studies, I have never read or > heard of any Scholar who had a different opinion than the one > shared by the ummah, that hazrat Muhammad(SAW) was the absolute > Last Prophet to be commissioned to mankind. > > Are you willing, before Allah(SWT) to swear that you have actually > read the books of the scholars you have mentioned and that what > you have alleged accurately represents their point of view? If you > have not read the books yourself, would you kindly tell us the > name of the individual whose writings you are relying on? > > As you know, it is extremely easy for people with special motives > to falsely attribute things to others, hoping that some careless > individuals may, out of loyalty to the movement they have been > born into or, perhaps, because they mistakenly believe to be > serving Islam, to spread the falsehood. As Allah(SWT) has advised > the believers, we are to verify such allegations. > > I believe this is a perfectly reasonable request, and Islamically > allowed. However, none of our Qadiani brothers appears to be > forthcoming with this information. I hope you will reply. > > Thank you. > > Original Article: http://www.egroups.com/list/qadianism/?start=15 > > Many great scholars and mugiaddeds had the opinion that > > prophethood was not finished and disagreed with the mullahs > > who invented this idea. Here are some of these past great > > scholars, that we Ahmadi Muslims agree with: > > > > 1. Hazrat Imam Shaikh Mohiyyiud-Din ibne Arabi; > > 2. Hazrat Maulvi Muhammad Qasim Nanotovi; > > 3. Hazrat Imam Abdul Wahhab She'raani; > > 4. The Muhaddith of Dehli, Hazrat Shah Wali Ullah Muhaddis; > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ eGroup home: http://www.eGroups.com/list/qadianism