[qadianism] Re: Finality of Prophethood - What is Qadiani View
By Irshad @irshad.org
6:25am
Thu
11
Feb

On Mon, 8 Feb 1999, Farhan Qureshi wrote:

> It is not Hadith I have spoken of, It is the Holy Qur'an which says
> that there are two or maybe three types of Prophethood: Insha'Allah
> Th'a'ala I will get the reference for you as soon as possible: Its
> just, the Qur'an is upstairs, so I have to look it up. 

Alhamdolellah, I teach a class of tafseer to adults and 
a class of memorization of Quran to actual children.  You
are not in need of going throught the trouble of getting 
your Quran.  You are forgetting, I am a Muslim and I know
Quran.

But, since you are a Qadiani, do you know the writings of
your leaders and founders?

Please pay close attention to the discussion.  I asked
about what your leaders have written, not what is written
in Quran or what Qadianis have now picked up from Bahai 
and Submitter's literature.  Please try to concentrate 
for a couple of minutes and, instead of name calling,
changing the subject, or running away, enlighten us with
the "wisdom" of your founders..

For someone who claims his job to be removing silly 
misunderstanding and falsehood about your Mission, you
are not off to a good start!  I've already took the trouble
to quote for you two of your founders, do you and other
Qadianis accept their teaching or do you reject and
ignore them, because you believe them to have been 
unlearned and misguided?

Thank you.

> > would you like to revise your statement or present proof to the
> > contrary?  Obviously, these high level leaders of your movement
> > disagree with your statement.  They say Messengers (rosol), or
> > prophets with Shariah, have ended; prophets (nabi) who received
> > prophethood from Allah(SWT) have also ended.  Only a special 
> > and new category of prophets, "zilli" or "ummati", according to
> > them, will continue.
> > 
> > According to Mirza Bashi Ahmad, the door to "zilli" or "ummati"
> > prophets was opened, after the death of Muhammad(SAW); while the
> > door to "Tashree" (rasul) and "mostaqel" (nabis without laws)
> > prophets, who used to be sent prior to him(SAW), has been closed.
> > 
> > Is this not a fair understanding of the real stated position 
> > of the Mission?
> > 
> > Thank you.
> > ===============================================================
> >  < 19990207175416.27465.rocketmai-@send105.yahoomail.com > wrote: 
> > Original Article: http://www.egroups.com/list/qadianism/?start=68
> > 


------------------------------------------------------------------------
eGroup home: http://www.eGroups.com/list/qadianism